From the May 1999 issue of SPIKE SPEAK

SPIKE SPEAK Bulletin May 1999

Technical Information on Power Protection for the Digital Office Automation Industry 
Neutral to Ground Bonding and TVSS (Surge Suppression) Systems

Surge Suppressor Manufacturers who claim to obtain zero or no voltage between neutral and ground using neutral to ground bonding are out of compliance with the provisions, below of The National Electrical Code and IEEE Standards.

Neutral to ground bonding remains a misunderstood and controversial subject within the Transient Voltage Surge Suppressor (TVSS) industry. Safety aspects of TVSS wiring are enforced by various local and national codes and are tested for safety by Underwriters Laboratories (UL) and numerous other independent testing laboratories.

In terms of overall wiring safety, The National Electrical Code (NEC) and the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) Standards are in general use throughout the United States.

In this regard, the NEC and the IEEE state that neutral to ground connections are generally not permitted. THE NEC States in Section 250-61 (b) Load Side Equipment "A grounded circuit conductor shall not be used for grounding non current-carrying metal parts of equipment on the load side of the service. . ."

"One major reason the grounded circuit conductor is not permitted to be grounded on the load side of the service is that, should the grounded service conductor become disconnected at any point on the line side of the ground, the equipment grounding conductor and all conductive parts connected to it will carry the neutral current, raising the potential to ground of exposed metal parts not normally intended to carry current. This could result in arcing in concealed places and could pose a severe shock hazard."

The IEEE States in Section 6.4.1.1.1 Neutral to Ground Bond ". . .neutral-ground bonds are a common problem that not only create shock hazards for operating personnel but can also degrade the performance of sensitive electronic equipment."

In some parts of Europe, Asia and the UK, ungrounded systems remain a convention. Based on the long-standing tradition of these ungrounded systems, it is obvious that such power systems can be made viable. However, the United States has followed a grounded approach, which is generally considered safer and contributes to improved system performance.

The Effect of Neutral to Ground Bonding on The Digital Office: Networked Computers, Copiers, and Faxes.
Single point grounding is a concept that should be followed in all networked, automated offices and computer installations, from mainframe to PC. In many cases, single point grounding already exists as the standard in most construction wiring design. The purpose of single point grounding is to prevent voltage differences from occurring between pieces of equipment. With each unit referencing to a single point of potential, no unwanted noise currents flow between them. This is critical to the proper function of interconnected / electrically connected, digital equipment. Multiple grounding points cause ground loops. These paths are a source of common mode noise that can cause a host of computer problems such as data corruption, error codes, printer and equipment lock-up.

In an effort to eliminate common mode noise, some TVSS Manufacturers have developed TVSSs that bond neutral to ground via a relay. Any TVSS that bonds neutral to ground, will appear effective in eliminating of noise for the protected equipment. However, it changes the ground reference of the protected equipment in relation to any connected equipment, (via LAN, Modem or data line) which increases the potential for common mode noise, that cause data corruption, error codes and lock-ups.

How do you test a TVSS for Neutral to Ground bonding.

The GFCI (Ground Fault Circuit Interrupt) Test:
A simple test to determine N-G bonding on a TVSS is the use of a GFCI outlet. N-G bonded TVSSs will send additional current back into the ground line, creating a ground fault. This current will trip a ground fault interrupt, thereby making it impossible to use an appliance or industrial grade GFCI outlet with a N-G Bonded TVSS.

The Suretest Test:
Plug a Suretest into the outlet receptacle of the suspect TVSS and let it run through its startup diagnostic. It will automatically show "FG" meaning "False" or "Bootleg" Ground.

References:
Mark Earley, National Electrical Code Handbook, Seventh Edition, National Fire Protection Association, Quincy MA, 1996
Morrison / Lewis
Grounding and Shielding in Facilities John Wiley & Sons, Inc. New York, NY, 1990
M. Waller,
PC Power Protection Howard W. Sams & Company, Indianapolis, IN, 1989
M. Waller,
Computer Electrical Power Requirements Howard W. Sams & Company, Indianapolis, IN, 1987
IEEE Recommended Practice for Powering and Grounding Sensitive Electronic Equipment, The Emerald Book, IEEE Std.

© Copyright - Smart Power Systems Inc.